Blue Diamond Defeats Class Certification in Consumer Deception Lawsuit
Share
A federal judge ruled in favor of Compass Lexecon client Blue Diamond Growers (“Blue Diamond”) in a class action lawsuit involving Illinois purchasers of Blue Diamond’s Smokehouse Almonds (“Plaintiffs”) who alleged that Blue Diamond misled consumers into believing that they were purchasing almonds smoked in a smokehouse, allowing Blue Diamond to charge higher prices. Plaintiffs sought class certification for damages and injunctive relief, including correction of the challenged practice.
Compass Lexecon Senior Consultant, Professor Peter E. Rossi was retained on behalf of Blue Diamond to address liability and damages issues, including rebutting Plaintiffs’ “deception” and “overpayment” damages theories, as well as related use of survey methodologies. Professor Rossi submitted two reports during the class-certification phase of the case.
On February 20, 2026, United States District Judge Jorge L. Alonso of the Northern District of Illinois denied class certification. The Court found that the named Plaintiff was “inadequate to serve as the class representative” because she “had knowledge of the alleged defect … yet she continued to purchase the product.”
Professor Rossi was supported by a Compass Lexecon team that included Niall MacMenamin, Vendela Fehrm, Zhaoning (Nancy) Wang, Donovan Kaddis, Liam Ziaja, Zsofia Sipos, and George Hochwarter. Compass Lexecon worked closely with attorneys from DLA Piper, including Colleen Carey Gulliver, Jason Kornmehl, and Bradley Jennings, who successfully represented Blue Diamond.